Song meaning of Criminal (From "American Horror Story") by American Horror Story Cast (Ft. Sarah Paulson)

"Criminal" by Fiona Apple, as performed by the American Horror Story Cast featuring Sarah Paulson, is a haunting and introspective song that delves into themes of guilt, redemption, and self-awareness. The lyrics paint a vivid picture of a protagonist who acknowledges their wrongdoings and seeks absolution for their actions.

In the opening verse, the protagonist confesses to being a "bad bad girl" who has been "careless with a delicate man." This sets the tone for the song, highlighting the destructive behavior and the consequences of hurting someone they care about. The line "When a girl will break a boy just because she can" reflects a sense of power and control that the protagonist may have wielded in the relationship, ultimately leading to regret and remorse.

The chorus serves as a plea for forgiveness and redemption, with the protagonist feeling like a "criminal" in need of a "good defense." The repeated refrain emphasizes the internal struggle and desire to make amends for the pain caused to the person they love. The line "Because he's all I ever knew of love" speaks to the deep connection and significance of the relationship, underscoring the importance of seeking forgiveness and reconciliation.

The bridge introduces a sense of urgency and desperation, with the protagonist seeking guidance and clarity on how to right their wrongs before facing the consequences. The imagery of heaven and hell, angels and devils, adds a layer of complexity to the internal conflict and moral dilemma faced by the protagonist.

Overall, "Criminal" is a poignant and emotionally charged song that explores the complexities of human relationships, guilt, and the quest for redemption. Fiona Apple's raw and powerful vocals, combined with the evocative lyrics, create a compelling narrative that resonates with listeners on a deep emotional level.