Song meaning of I’m in the Middle of a Riddle by Fiona Apple (Ft. Maude Maggart)

"I'm in the Middle of a Riddle" by Fiona Apple featuring Maude Maggart is a poignant and introspective song that delves into the complexities of unrequited love and the uncertainty that comes with it. The lyrics express the narrator's deep feelings for someone, yet also their confusion and frustration at not receiving the same level of affection in return.

The opening verse sets the tone for the song, with the narrator questioning the sincerity of their love interest: "Are you true? I wish I knew." This line reflects the doubt and insecurity that often accompany one-sided love. The repeated refrain of being "in the middle of a riddle" emphasizes the confusion and emotional turmoil the narrator is experiencing due to their unreciprocated feelings.

The chorus highlights the narrator's internal struggle, as they express their love openly but suspect that their partner may be hiding something: "Though I show I love you so, I've got a feeling you're concealing something that I ought to know." This juxtaposition of outward affection and underlying doubt encapsulates the heartache of loving someone who may not feel the same way.

The bridge reinforces the central theme of the song, with the narrator reiterating their love for the other person despite the pain it causes: "I'm in the middle of a riddle 'cause I'm so in love with you, right in the middle of a riddle 'cause you won't belong to me." This internal conflict between love and longing for reciprocation is a common struggle in relationships.

Overall, "I'm in the Middle of a Riddle" is a beautifully crafted song that captures the emotional complexity of unrequited love. Fiona Apple's emotive vocals, combined with Maude Maggart's haunting harmonies, create a haunting and evocative atmosphere that resonates with anyone who has experienced the bittersweetness of loving someone who may not feel the same way.